Safest pacifiers, ranked

59 brands ranked by a transparent safety score: CPSC recall history (weighted by severity and recency) balanced against safety certifications. This ranks brands by safety record, not product quality — and a recall isn't proof a brand is unsafe, nor is its absence proof it's safe.

1. #1
   Allreds Design dba Hidden Hollow Beads 1 recall(s)
   97

   Safety rank

   Check price
2. #2B
   Binky-Griptight 1 recall(s)
   97

   Safety rank

   Check price
3. #3H
   H. Bender And Sons 1 recall(s)
   97

   Safety rank

   Check price
4. #4G
   Grow Time 1 recall(s)
   96

   Safety rank

   Check price
5. #5
   Apothecary Products 1 recall(s)
   93

   Safety rank

   Check price
6. #6B
   Baby Buddies 1 recall(s)
   93

   Safety rank

   Check price
7. #7C
   Casa Felix 1 recall(s)
   93

   Safety rank

   Check price
8. #8
   Chewbeads 1 recall(s)
   93

   Safety rank

   Check price
9. #9
   CPSC, California International Trading 1 recall(s)
   93

   Safety rank

   Check price
10. #10
    CPSC, Delta Enterprise 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
11. #11
    CPSC, Ideal Distributors 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
12. #12
    CPSC, Natura Products Downey 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
13. #13
    CPSC, Rashti & Rashti 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
14. #14
    CPSC, Solar 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
15. #15
    CPSC, The Elegant Kids 2000 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
16. #16
    CPSC, Todo Dollar Wholesale 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
17. #17E
    Eugene Trading 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
18. #18G
    Glenco Infants Items 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
19. #19
    Grand World 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
20. #20
    It's MY Binky 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
21. #21L
    Lerma Import 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
22. #22M
    MJ Harris and Associates 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
23. #23M
    Monterey Laboratories 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
24. #24R
    Red Carpet Distribution 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
25. #25
    Sandbox Medical 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
26. #26
    Small Beginnings 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
27. #27S
    Steven Barrie and 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
28. #28
    Tahoe Enterprises 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
29. #29
    Top Goods Trading 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
30. #30U
    University Hospitals 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
31. #31W
    WB Nod 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
32. #32W
    Winn Dixie 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
33. #33
    Yi Wu Jiangyi Plastic 1 recall(s)
    93

    Safety rank

    Check price
34. #34C
    Claire's Boutiques 1 recall(s)
    91

    Safety rank

    Check price
35. #35D
    Dolax 1 recall(s)
    91

    Safety rank

    Check price
36. #36
    Shims Bargain 1 recall(s)
    91

    Safety rank

    Check price
37. #37
    Sassy 2 recall(s)
    91

    Safety rank

    Check price
38. #38F
    Four Seasons General Mdse 2 recall(s)
    88

    Safety rank

    Check price
39. #39
    FRIGG Production ApS / FB Trading ApS 1 recall(s)
    87

    Safety rank

    Check price
40. #40
    Yangzhou Rich Arts & Crafts 1 recall(s)
    87

    Safety rank

    Check price
41. #41
    Fred & Friends 2 recall(s)
    87

    Safety rank

    Check price
42. #42K
    Kiddie Products 2 recall(s)
    87

    Safety rank

    Check price
43. #43L
    La Cibeles 2 recall(s)
    87

    Safety rank

    Check price
44. #44
    Playtex 2 recall(s)
    87

    Safety rank

    Check price
45. #45T
    Tidy 2 recall(s)
    87

    Safety rank

    Check price
46. #46
    JA-RU 3 recall(s)
    87

    Safety rank

    Check price
47. #47
    Playtex Products 3 recall(s)
    81

    Safety rank

    Check price
48. #48D
    Dan Brechner 3 recall(s)
    80

    Safety rank

    Check price
49. #49
    Munchkin 4 recall(s)
    65

    Safety rank

    Check price
50. #50
    Bath and Body Works 5 recall(s)
    63

    Safety rank

    Check price
51. #51
    Hobby Lobby 5 recall(s)
    46

    Safety rank

    Check price
52. #52
    Epoch Everlasting Play 3 recall(s)
    42

    Safety rank

    Check price
53. #53
    Hasbro 11 recall(s)
    39

    Safety rank

    Check price
54. #54
    Gerber 12 recall(s)
    33

    Safety rank

    Check price
55. #55
    Big Lots 10 recall(s)
    27

    Safety rank

    Check price
56. #56
    Evenflo 17 recall(s)

    JPMA CertifiedFMVSS 213
    3

    Safety rank

    Check price
57. #57
    Kmart 21 recall(s)
    0

    Safety rank

    Check price
58. #58
    Toys“R”Us 29 recall(s)
    0

    Safety rank

    Check price
59. #59
    Target 56 recall(s)
    0

    Safety rank

    Check price

Ranking combines public CPSC recall data with curated certification listings. The score is a safety signal, not a guarantee, and reflects brand-level (not model-level) data. Confirm current recall and certification status before buying. Some links are affiliate links — see our disclosure.