Safest fireplaces & accessories, ranked

18 brands ranked by a transparent safety score: CPSC recall history (weighted by severity and recency) balanced against safety certifications. This ranks brands by safety record, not product quality — and a recall isn't proof a brand is unsafe, nor is its absence proof it's safe.

1. #1F
   Fireplace Technologies 1 recall(s)
   97

   Safety rank

   Check price
2. #2
   Agio International , Limited 1 recall(s)
   91

   Safety rank

   Check price
3. #3
   American Flame 1 recall(s)
   91

   Safety rank

   Check price
4. #4
   Bluworld/Nu-Flame 1 recall(s)
   91

   Safety rank

   Check price
5. #5
   Central Fireplace 1 recall(s)
   91

   Safety rank

   Check price
6. #6
   CFM 1 recall(s)
   91

   Safety rank

   Check price
7. #7M
   Marco Mfg 1 recall(s)
   91

   Safety rank

   Check price
8. #8
   Pascal Products 1 recall(s)
   91

   Safety rank

   Check price
9. #9
   Plow & Hearth 1 recall(s)
   91

   Safety rank

   Check price
10. #10V
    Valor Heating 1 recall(s)
    91

    Safety rank

    Check price
11. #11
    Wolf Steel USA 1 recall(s)
    91

    Safety rank

    Check price
12. #12
    Simpson Dura-Vent 1 recall(s)
    90

    Safety rank

    Check price
13. #13
    DESA Heating Products 2 recall(s)
    82

    Safety rank

    Check price
14. #14
    Heat & Glo 2 recall(s)
    82

    Safety rank

    Check price
15. #15
    Lennox Hearth Products 3 recall(s)
    72

    Safety rank

    Check price
16. #16
    Hearth & Home Technologies 5 recall(s)
    61

    Safety rank

    Check price
17. #17J
    JC Penney 8 recall(s)
    42

    Safety rank

    Check price
18. #18
    Meijer 13 recall(s)
    0

    Safety rank

    Check price

Ranking combines public CPSC recall data with curated certification listings. The score is a safety signal, not a guarantee, and reflects brand-level (not model-level) data. Confirm current recall and certification status before buying. Some links are affiliate links — see our disclosure.