All rankings
Safest fireplaces & accessories, ranked
18 brands ranked by a transparent safety score: CPSC recall history (weighted by severity and recency) balanced against safety certifications. This ranks brands by safety record, not product quality — and a recall isn't proof a brand is unsafe, nor is its absence proof it's safe.
- #1Fireplace Technologies 1 recall(s)Check price97Safety rank
- #2
Agio International , Limited 1 recall(s)Check price91Safety rank - #3
American Flame 1 recall(s)Check price91Safety rank - #4
Bluworld/Nu-Flame 1 recall(s)Check price91Safety rank - #5
Central Fireplace 1 recall(s)Check price91Safety rank - #6
CFM 1 recall(s)Check price91Safety rank - #7Marco Mfg 1 recall(s)Check price91Safety rank
- #8
Pascal Products 1 recall(s)Check price91Safety rank - #9
Plow & Hearth 1 recall(s)Check price91Safety rank - #10Valor Heating 1 recall(s)Check price91Safety rank
- #11
Wolf Steel USA 1 recall(s)Check price91Safety rank - #12
Simpson Dura-Vent 1 recall(s)Check price90Safety rank - #13
DESA Heating Products 2 recall(s)Check price82Safety rank - #14
Heat & Glo 2 recall(s)Check price82Safety rank - #15
Lennox Hearth Products 3 recall(s)Check price72Safety rank - #16
Hearth & Home Technologies 5 recall(s)Check price61Safety rank - #17JC Penney 8 recall(s)Check price42Safety rank
- #18
Meijer 13 recall(s)Check price0Safety rank
Ranking combines public CPSC recall data with curated certification listings. The score is a safety signal, not a guarantee, and reflects brand-level (not model-level) data. Confirm current recall and certification status before buying. Some links are affiliate links — see our disclosure.